Charge of electron in AC/DC circuit part II

This is a conversation that came from a previous question, but brought to birth a new question:

" They pick up energy from the electric field which passes through the wire between the terminals. It accelerates the electrons, and they release this energy when they collide with something. " - This part right here is interesting. This may have been explained to me before, but I've never heard it put that way. "" electric field which passes through the wire between the terminals "" what are you trying to say. That once the switch has been turned " on " or connection has been made between both potential sides, the potential difference from one side instantly (speed of light) – Mac R. Jul 24 at 20:13

continued: runs across the wire no matter what the distance to meet the other side of potential difference at the load or switch to remain polar opposites of potential on either side of it to be able to " accelerate " the electrons ( in a DC circuit). – Mac R. Jul 24 at 20:19

Going back to AC, " They do not become positively charged under any circumstances " so then how is positive current possible in AC circuit. The sine wave starts e.g. 120V at +1 V then peaks at +120V then descends to 0V then descends further to -120V to return ascending again back to 0V. The positive voltage and current thereafter was only possible because of the positive charge present in that space of travel (in the wire), right or wrong. – Mac R. Jul 24 at 20:22

Positive/negative voltage is unconnected to positive/negative charge. The negative and positive voltages of an alternating current express that the electric field keeps changing its direction, not that it changes what type of charges are the basis for the field. – zwol Jul 24 at 23:58

@zwol that's very helpful. thank you. – Mac R. Jul 26 at 4:20

@zwol I was told that positive/negative potential tells/forces which way positive/negative current (charge) will go. – Mac R. Jul 26 at 15:03

I believe that's another way of saying the same thing. The direction of the electric field vector at any point will be the direction in which current flows. When we're talking about electric circuits, the field will (to first order) always point along the wire, so we can talk about "positive or negative" voltage instead of a full 3D vector field. – zwol Jul 26 at 15:12

@zwol "not that it changes what type of charges are the basis for the field. " - " positive/negative potential tells which way positive/negative current (charge) goes ". I am failing to see how both those statements are " saying the same thing. " – Mac R. Jul 26 at 22:00

The statements that are saying the same thing are "negative and positive voltages of an alternating current express that the electric field keeps changing its direction" and "positive/negative potential tells which way positive/negative current goes". However, notice that I deleted "(charge)". Positive/negative current is also only about direction, not about charge of the carriers. Read very carefully. – zwol Jul 27 at 14:25

@zwol " However, notice that I deleted "(charge)". "all right. Which brings us back to the post's question. "" Or is it that the electron carries only a positive charge in the first half of the cycle and then upon returning on the second half, it only carries a negative charge? "" if AC is positive current going one way in one half of the 50 hz cycle and negative current in the other half, and positive current is a flow of positive charge, then the electrons must carry that positive charge. Or so it seems in that " thought process ", is it wrong. – Mac R. 2 days ago

@zwol p.s. I already know about " convention ", this question was born from all that. – Mac R. 2 days ago

"AC is positive current [that is, current going one way] in one half of the 50 hz cycle, and negative current [that is, current going the other way] in the other half" - correct. "and positive current is a flow of positive charge" - wrong. Positive current is only about direction, like I said. – zwol 2 days ago

@zwol "" "and positive current is a flow of positive charge" - wrong "" I want to believe that soo bad. where can I find a factual academic text or article that states that same sentence. – **Mac R. yesterday******

I already pointed you at Note in particular: "A flow of positive charges gives the same electric current, and has the same effect in a circuit, as an equal flow of negative charges in the opposite direction. Since current can be the flow of either positive or negative charges, or both, a convention is needed for the direction of current that is independent of the type of charge carriers. The direction of conventional current is arbitrarily defined as the same direction as positive charges flow." – zwol yesterday

(If you don't feel Wikipedia is sufficiently reliable, you should go to your local public library and ask at the reference desk for a high-school-level "electricity and magnetism" textbook.) – zwol yesterday

I am starting to think that in the " Electrodynamic Community " people are calling the flow of electrons through a wire: AMPs and the flow of charge Current. Is this correct or not. – Mac R. yesterday

@zwol " Since current can be the flow of either positive or negative charges, or both, a convention is needed for the direction of current that is independent of the type of charge carriers " but through a WIRE only electrons can flow, so I fail to see how in either DC or AC their can be positive current flow of positive charges if protons don't flow through WIRE. – Mac R. yesterday

(1) In a wire made of metal, only electrons can flow, yes. (2) Therefore, there can't be a flow of positive charges in a wire, but there can be a flow of positive current in a wire, implemented by electrons flowing in the opposite direction. (3) Amps and current are the same thing. More accurately, "amp" is the name of the unit of measure for current. – zwol yesterday

@zwol so we have established that at least in AC there is no positive charge present in either of the cycle halves and that in DC it might be the same. Also that, negative current and positive current through a WIRE is just the name given to either direction the ELECTRONS will flow/bump along due to push/force/accerlation from either of electric fields direction of travel running around/over the distance of the wire in an invisible field similar to a invisible magnetic field. if the previous is correct,

then where does charge ( negative, because in a wire ) come into play

. – Mac R. 17 hours ago
Post's question is highlighted


Category: charge Time: 2016-07-30 Views: 0
Tags: charge

Related post

  • Will a device charger with higher current output necessarily charge an electronic device faster? 2013-09-29

    Charger specs Charger type : USB Charger Voltage : 5V Amp : 2 Amp Freq : 60 Hz Battery specs Type : Li-ion Power : 7.4 Wh Current : 2 Ah Discharge Voltage : 3.7 V Charging limit voltage : 4.2 V Charging limit current : Not specified Execution Criteri

  • Where exactly do the electrons go in the circuit once they traverse the circuit elements? 2012-10-31

    From my understanding, when a voltage is applied to a circuit the free electrons in the circuit elements start moving towards the higher voltage potential. So what happens once the electrons reach the the higher voltage potential? It doesn't make muc

  • Charging capacitor bank with current limiting circuit 2012-09-04

    I would like to charge a capacitor bank with a 4.8 volt supply that I have. With the help received in response to this question, I now have a a useful current limiting circuit (shown below), that allows me to select a maximum current through a load.

  • How to set up a LiPo battery to be able to charge and discharge from the same circuit 2014-06-18

    I am new to using rechargeable batteries in electronics projects. To give some background on the context of the project, I'm trying to build a solar charger/power pack for a cell phone. My problem is that I'm not sure how to connect the battery in th

  • Flexible Watch Circuit Parts 2011-07-12

    I'm working on a project to make a wristwatch similar to this one: Now I have the ability to make flexible PCBs since I accidentally bought some crazy thin copper clad. I obviously want to use SMD LEDs since they're pretty small. What type of \$\mu \

  • Electronic Plant Watering System Circuit 2014-05-05

    I have recently seen one of very interesting concepts and it's circuit diagram is present in the page: Electronic Plant Watering System. I felt that it is very useful in our real life also when we go for any tours. Coming to my problem, I have a smal

  • What is the capacitor charging time when charged with a pnp current mirror circuit? 2013-04-29

    I want to use a 555 in monostable mode to make a ramp signal generator. The capacitor would be charged using a current mirror circuit. Given a input voltage, what would be the charging time of capacitor? My understanding is: \$ \dfrac{V}{V-V_{EB}} \c

  • Capacitor charging: do electrons migrate from the source to the dielectric? 2014-05-30

    Encyclopedia of Electronic Components - Vol1, pg:98 by Charles Platt Electrons from the power source will migrate on­ to the plate attached to the negative side of the source, and will tend to repel electrons from the other plate. This may be thought

  • Different time constants for charging and discharging of modified RC circuit 2014-11-09

    I recently performed a test in an electrical measurements lab which left me confused. I measured the response of the following circuit: And obtained the following output: According to my professor, the charging and discharging of the capacitor has di

  • Charging li-ion batteries with protection circuit 2014-12-20

    If i'm using a protection circuit like this one: and 4, 3.7v li-ion batteries. Can I use a simple 16.8v dc wall wart to charge them? or do I still need a special l

  • Do I need a balance charger if i use a Protection Circuit Module for Li-ion batteries? 2015-01-14

    I'm looking into making a battery pack for a portable speaker system. If I use one of these:

  • What's the purpose of the diode in this selectable supply voltage circuit part 2015-05-12

    I'm looking at the power supply part of the schematic of SparkFun's Pro Micro Arduino board, which has a jumper to enable or disable a voltage regulator to select between running the board at 3.3V or 5V: I have two questions about D2: What is its fun

  • Calculating the time for current reducing to zero from a charged inductor in a series LC circuit 2015-12-31

    I'm wondering how you calculate the time taken for the current in a charged inductor to reduce to zero with the only current path being through a capacitor. I'm looking at this from the perspective of an unloaded boost converter where at the end of t

  • Charging battery in a simple UPS circuit 2016-07-20

    I have used this circuit to switch between main power and battery. Is it possible to charge the battery (Lead acid or LI-ION) with D1 or a new circuit is needed for charging?

  • Voltage divider with short circuit part 2 2014-05-13

    – Schematic created using CircuitLab This question is a slightly modified follow-up to my previous question Voltage divider with a short, what is Vout? In this voltage divider I was originally wondering what \$V_{out}\$ was when a short was created a

  • USB charging and powering circuit with MAX1555 and MAX1881 2013-05-09

    I'm new to (rechargeable) battery powered devices, but I found the following article about using the MAX1555 and MAX1881 for building a charging (via USB) and powering (µC-circuit, 3.3V, max. ~70mA) circuit. They describe the following diagram: The M

  • Will voltage or current determine a diode drop for this battery charging circuit? 2014-06-30

    I am using a li-ion battery charger IC that regulates an output to 4.2V. I have a schottky diode in series with the output that then connects to the battery. How do I determine the voltage drop? If the charger puts out 100mA do I go by the VI curve o

  • Double Li-ion charging circuit logic 2014-08-10

    I'm currently trying to adapt a single li-ion battery charger based on the TP4056 to work with charging more than one battery. The idea is to use a logic circuit that is controlled by the IC's "FULL" output signal. Whenever the first battery is

  • Can an electron carry only one charge? 2014-10-18

    Sorry if this has been asked before. Could also be a really basic question (new to electrical study). I am a bit confused about the relationship between electrons and charges. So what I understand is this: (1) One coulomb of charge has 6.24 x 10^18 e

iOS development

Android development

Python development

JAVA development

Development language

PHP development

Ruby development


Front-end development


development tools

Open Platform

Javascript development

.NET development

cloud computing


Copyright (C), All Rights Reserved.

processed in 0.679 (s). 13 q(s)