Consumer Reports' WebWatch Conference on Search Advertising

U.S. readers will probably recognize “Consumer Reports” more than folks in other countries, but over here they’ve got quite a reputation for unbiased reporting and product testing as well as consumer advocacy.

On June 9, I will be speaking at a conference sponsored by Consumer Reports WebWatch titled
Trust or Consequence: How Failure to Disclose Ad Relationships Threatens to Burst the Search Bubble

The discussion will center around the idea that search engines risk their credibility for the sake of short term gain, when they fail to fully disclose paid advertising relationships. I won’t go off on a long rant about why in the heck the words “Sponsored Listings” would be displayed in light gray text, because we all know why.

What I do plan to bring to the conference is a bit of perspective from advertisers. As much as searchers may be misled, deceived, or simply confused by what’s shown on the SERPs, what PPC providers don’t disclose to advertisers is just as disturbing in many cases.

How many PPC advertisers think they’re targeting search, when in fact a high percentage of their ad displays and click-throughs come from expired domains (or for a couple hilarious weeks, mistyped domains), pop-ups and pop-unders, adware/scumware, etc.? Do the PPC providers openly disclose this side of their distribution network, or do they sort of admit to “having a partnership” when they get cornered? Do they give advertisers any real control over it?

For those who are interested, a study from WebWatch on how and what search engines actually disclose:


Category: marketing Time: 2005-04-21 Views: 2

Related post

  • Custom report for tracking webiste search within specific page 2011-04-12

    I've got a search page in my website: It presents an HTML form with method="get" for searching the site so a search for "test" will result in url: There is also pagi

  • Report with Subtotals - In Search Of An Abstraction 2015-10-19

    High Level Explanation of Code's Purpose I wrote a class to create sectioned reports, where each section has a subtotal. It allows these reports to be nested within each other, to create multiple levels of subtotals. An example will help clarify the

  • SitePoint SEM Kit reviewed at Search Engine Watch 2005-06-13

    Chris Sherman of Search Engine Watch has written a nice review of the SitePoint SEM Kit for Search Day, which was posted last week while I was in Berkeley for the Consumer Reports Webwatch conference. This review likens our SEM kit to the "internet i

  • Search, Display and Retargeting: The Holy Trinity of Online Advertising 2014-02-18

    It's difficult to convince budget-conscious small business owners that they need to invest their marketing dollars into multiple channels. Many are hoping to find the one "silver bullet" that will release a floodgate of hungry buyers. But advert

  • Search queries report empty after moving site to HTTPS 2015-10-28

    I've noticed a few awkward bumps in analytics/search when moving my site from http to https, but almost all of them worked their way out...but the Aquisition > SEO > Queries report in Google Analyitics acts as if I got 0 impressions ever since SSL w

  • Social Search is Not the Future 2008-07-10

    I read something a couple of weeks ago that gave me pause. Not because it was so profound, or so mind bending, shocking, or inspiring. What gave me pause was how completely I think it misses the mark. What I read was an article in AdAge that predicte

  • Beware of Becoming Search-dependent 2009-04-03

    Shayne is reporting this week from Search Marketing Expo in Sydney. In the first session of SMX Sydney, Rand Fishkin, CEO of SEOmoz told the story of a recent startup that woke up one morning to find their organic search engine traffic from Google ha

  • Where/How do you search for information on the Internet? 2009-08-03

    Google Search or Search Engine wins; no contest. What I want is the specialist content in websites dedicated to something. The site where you go to search the specific information you want. Say: You woke up today and wanted to know about Household Ap

  • Best guidelines for bug reporting? 2011-10-09

    Nothing can ruin your day like a poorly-written bug report. I've seen several sets of guidelines for bug reporting in different organizations. In your opinion, what guidelines/steps are most essential for good bug reporting? Feel free to share comple

  • IBM Cognos for BI Reporting 2009-04-30

    I would like to setup a business intelligence dashboard that reports on current system health. How difficult is Cognos in terms of setup, and when it comes to developing the dashboard does it use its own proprietary scripting language? --------------

  • What is a podcast and how do I find one and consume it 2009-08-31

    What is a podcast, how do I find one and how do I consume it (or whatever you call consuming one). --------------Solutions------------- Podcasts are usually topic specific audio programs like radio talk shows. Most podcasts can be aggregated using th

  • How can I manually generate the Web Analytics Report? 2010-11-23

    How can I manually trigger generation of the Web Analytics Report for Traffic and Search in SharePoint 2010? It seems to run once a day. --------------Solutions------------- This report is generated by a timer job that can be run manually. Try these

  • Using search and replace to remove line breaks in Open Office 2011-01-15

    I've imported a document into Open Office and it has a number of hard returns in wrong places. In MS Word, I could use the search and replace to simply get rid of them all easily, but Open Office's search won't find them. I tried /n with the 'use reg

  • How to avoid duplicated bug reports, described from different user perspective? 2011-05-25

    We get a lot of bug reports that ends up as the same bug, but are described through the eyes of a different user. For example one can see a device has crashed, the other sees communications loss and the third will see that she can't install a driver

  • Windows remote access server (PPTP) advertised routes 2011-12-19

    How does a routing and remote access server pick up routes to advertise to clients, and where can a list of routes being provided be reviewed? One of our users is reporting that the server is advertising a route which is valid, but has never been ent

  • Global monthly searches versus results 2012-02-14

    I compiled a report with global monthly searches last week for my boss, regarding SEO (this is from Google AdWords). He, however, seems to want a report of the results for a specific keyword - is there a way to get this information? --------------Sol

  • Why would Exchange 2010 Delivery Reports show random results? 2012-02-23

    Looking for ideas on how to troubleshoot. MY Delivery Reports in ECP or Search-MessageTrackingReport in EMS will yeild what seems like random results for both internal an external email tracking. By random I mean only a small subset will show up. I'v

  • Search Engine Marketing: What Every Online Business Needs to Know 2012-08-14

    The world of online marketing has been growing at an accelerated pace, and many techniques have emerged to help businesses promote themselves on the web. These techniques have evolved with time and become more efficient in terms of performance and co

  • Sharepoint 2010 with existing SQL Reporting Services 2012-08-30

    going through my list for things I need to prep for in my upcoming Sharepoint 2010 installation. We'll be installing SP2010 Enterprise to make use of the BI components, with the web server on it's own VM. We'll then use our existing SQL Server (2005)

iOS development

Android development

Python development

JAVA development

Development language

PHP development

Ruby development


Front-end development


development tools

Open Platform

Javascript development

.NET development

cloud computing


Copyright (C), All Rights Reserved.

processed in 0.771 (s). 13 q(s)