HTML5 Working Group Rejects Open Media Formats

HTML5 Working Group Rejects Open Media Formats
The HTML5 spec looks set to introduce new audio and video capabilities into the language, but the HTML5 working group has become embroiled in a debate over the codecs that browsers should support for them.

Nokia and Apple have succeeded in removing Ogg Vorbis and Theora from the current draft, citing patent uncertainties (read: a reluctance to back a standard that has no provision for including DRM).

Manuel Amador has detailed why he believes the decision to omit these open formats to be an “outrageous disaster”:

(Given) the fact that there are widely available patent-free implementations of Ogg technology, there is really no excuse for Apple and Nokia to say that they couldn’t in good faith implement HTML5 as previously formulated.

And Ian Hickson from the WHATWG has responded with his own version of why it doesn’t make sense for Ogg Vorbis or Theora to be included (primarily, because Nokia and Apple are supposedly worried about being sued for using the format).

Regardless of the true motivations, it feels like this is a step backwards for HTML and for digital media in general.


Category: programming Time: 2007-12-13 Views: 2

Related post

  • Six Months Later: The New HTML Working Group 2007-05-10

    The following is republished from the Tech Times #164. Because I just wasn't getting enough email (ha!), I joined the W3C's new HTML Working Group last month. Nearly six months ago, now, Tim Berners-Lee announced that the W3C would form a new working

  • What media formats are supported in Android? 2015-09-24

    I am new to Android, and I'm learning. For example, most of my old music files were FLV and SWF files, which my phone and tablet won't play, and I can't seem to get extensions for Chrome to play them. The file manager on my tablet seems to play MP4 f

  • Clarke Calls for CSS Working Group to be Disbanded 2007-12-19

    Having recently announced the CSS Eleven initiative to provide designer feedback and input into the W3C's CSS Working Group, Andy Clarke has responded to the Opera-Microsoft antitrust action by calling for the Group to be dissolved entirely and rebui

  • What media formats are playable/streamable on Apple TV? 2010-09-02

    For both the new (tiny) generation, and the last generation, what media formats and codecs are supported for streaming to Apple TV? How does that streaming work -- is it all iTunes-based, or are there other ways to go about doing it? --------------So

  • TinyMCE doesn't work correctly in the Media Modal Window 2011-11-11

    I need to add TinyMCE to descriptions of images. For it, I'm using this code in my functions.php: function add_tiny_mce_hook() { if (function_exists('wp_tiny_mce')){ wp_tiny_mce(false, array( 'remove_linebreaks' => false, 'mode' => 'textareas', 'edi

  • Working on an open source game 2012-02-16

    Possible Duplicate: How can I get involved with open source game projects? I am trying to get involved in working on an open sourced basic game, but I've never attempted this before. I haven't the slightest clue how to go about this, what I should kn

  • Recovering Open Document Format Files and OLE in one go 2012-05-06

    Is there a recovery program that recovers both OLE files (MS Office files, i.e. .doc, .docx) and Open Document Format files (Libre/Open Office ones, i.e .odt) on Ubuntu 12.04? I deleted these files with Shift+Delete. --------------Solutions----------

  • Mavericks Server /Work group manager issues 2014-07-11

    I upgraded a test server running snow leopard to mavericks and then was having some weirdness so I decided to recreate my open directory, users and groups. Server appears to be running and I am able to connect from a laptop /user But... Work group ma

  • Suggest software for iOS to open Open Document formats (offline) 2015-12-15

    I haven't found any working software for my iPad which can open Open Document Formats (odt, ods, odp). ODP and ODT are the most proip. Morevoer this software should work offline, because I do not have internet access on my job. OOReader crashes, othe

  • Setup Windows 8 as Time server in no-Internet LAN(Work group) 2016-06-28

    I have 2 machines: Windows XP and Windows 8, in a no internet work group LAN. Now I want make the Windows 8 works as the time server to allow and handle Windows XP (as the client) time sync request, I've searched this post: Setup Win7 as time server

  • Messaging Anti Abuse Working Group 2004-11-02

    Just how much is spam and malicious email attempts costing you and your staff, clients and partners? That is a big question. And for many who run their business solo - difficult to assess the true costs to themselves and their customers. However, whe

  • News Wire: Chris Wilson to Chair W3C HTML Working Group 2007-01-12

    The Adobe PDF XSS Vulnerability A new XSS vulnerability has been found in Acrobat and Acrobat Reader 7.0.8 and earlier for Windows. If a vulnerable user follows a malicious link to a PDF on your site, the browser will silently execute the attacker's

  • News Wire: W3C Launches HTML Working Group 2007-03-09

    W3C Relaunches HTML Activity The W3C's new HTML working group, co-chaired by Microsoft's Chris Wilson and the W3C's Dan Connolly, was launched today. The group aims to have the next HTML recommendation out in 2010 (less than 4 years from now), and to

  • Coming Soon: Changes to the CSS Working Group? 2008-01-04

    In a previous post I reported on the crisis within the web standards community, and in particular the controversy surrounding the W3C CSS Working Group. It seems the criticism levelled by Andy Clarke and others has not fallen on deaf ears, because a

  • Microsoft Wipes Out Open Document Formats 2008-02-25

    With its announcement on Thursday that it was committed to interoperability, Microsoft successfully sent's OpenDocument formats to an early grave, presenting its own file formats as the industry standard that everyone should support. O

  • What media formats do I have to use to prevent Zune from having to convert media for Windows Phone? 2011-04-20

    Zune is able to accept pretty much every media format under the sun, or at least can once someone's installed something like the KLite Codec Pack. However, it does do conversion on your behalf to a more supported format when you try to sync the conte

  • What media formats supported by LR for embedding metadata? 2012-03-30

    I am writing an article about migrating Lightroom catalogs to Daminion via XMP metadata. Does anybody know what media formats supported by LR for embedding metadata. Except JPEG and TIFF formats. --------------Solutions------------- Lightroom stores

  • Unable to play proprietary media formats even after installing restricted extras 2012-04-02

    I have installed Ubuntu 12.04. I am unable to play proprietary media formats on Ubuntu Precise even after installing Ubuntu-Restricted-Extras. I am using Totem and Rhytmbox as my players. --------------Solutions------------- Install gstreamer0.10-ffm

  • Anyone else experiencing this problem: Firefox menus reliably stop working whenever I open a web page from the HUD 2012-07-24

    Firefox is 14.01, ubuntu is 12.04 latest updates. Unity 3d. Regardless of what I'm doing in Firefox menus will stop working if I open a web page from the HUD. If I run Firefox normally everything works normal, if I then open a link, say from the ask

iOS development

Android development

Python development

JAVA development

Development language

PHP development

Ruby development


Front-end development


development tools

Open Platform

Javascript development

.NET development

cloud computing


Copyright (C), All Rights Reserved.

processed in 1.486 (s). 13 q(s)